FIA Stewards Support Emerges in Behind-the-Scenes Insight After US GP Controversy
Read next: Formula 1 World Champions — A legacy of racing legends
Anthony Davidson reflects on the FIA stewards' decisions during the US Grand Prix, offering behind-the-scenes insights and discussing the challenges of being a steward in Formula 1.
In the world of Formula 1, the stewards play a crucial role in upholding the rules and maintaining fairness during each race. However, their decisions often spark controversy and debate. After the dramatic US Grand Prix in Austin, former F1 driver and now Sky Sports analyst Anthony Davidson offered a behind-the-scenes look into the stewards' decision-making process and the challenges they face in making difficult calls.
Anthony Davidson's Role as a F1 Analyst
To millions of motorsport fans, Anthony Davidson is a familiar face when it comes to analyzing Formula 1 incidents. Armed with his SkyPad, the 45-year-old former driver provides in-depth analysis of key moments in the race, offering viewers a detailed understanding of what happened on track. During the US Grand Prix, Davidson provided expert commentary on the controversial lap-52 pass between Lando Norris and Max Verstappen, a moment that ultimately shaped the podium positions.
Davidson's in-depth analysis, combined with his knowledge of how the stewards approach these situations, led him to conclude that Norris, despite both drivers leaving the track, was more at fault in the incident. As a result, Davidson supported the stewards' decision to give Norris a five-second penalty, pointing out that it was consistent with previous cases in similar situations.
Davidson’s View on the Stewards' Decision
While Davidson’s analysis received widespread approval from fans on social media, he was quick to clarify that his opinion was just that—his own perspective. "When I give my opinions, I’m only basing them on my 34 years of experience behind the wheel," Davidson explained. "It’s not like it should be definitive, it’s not like I’m the oracle." He emphasized that his role as an analyst is to offer an informed viewpoint, but he is not the one making the final decisions when it comes to penalties.
Davidson also expressed his empathy for the stewards, who have the challenging task of making decisions in real-time based on the rules and the context of the incident. "I would hate being a steward," Davidson admitted. "It’s a very difficult job, and I’m always surprised when people see me as the end point in any discussion. I think we need to recognize how hard it is for stewards to make these calls." He added that racing drivers do not have the luxury of reviewing incidents from multiple angles during the race, which makes their decisions even more challenging.
Understanding the Framework of Racing Regulations
Davidson highlighted the importance of the racing rulebook in guiding the stewards' decisions. According to Davidson, the stewards work within a clearly defined framework of dos and don’ts, which they have agreed upon with the teams and drivers. This framework allows them to apply the regulations consistently, ensuring fairness in the decision-making process.
"The stewards have basically created a blueprint, almost like a computer program, where they go through a checklist: Did this happen? Did that happen? Based on that, the result is clear," Davidson explained. He went on to say that while he might not always agree with the outcome of a specific incident from a racing perspective, he understands why the stewards make their decisions when viewed through the lens of the established rules.
Support for In-Race Decisions
One aspect of the stewarding process that Davidson strongly supports is the practice of making in-race decisions rather than delaying penalties long after the race has concluded. Reflecting on past incidents, Davidson pointed out that it is much better for fans and participants to know the result of a race promptly, rather than waiting for a delayed decision that could change the outcome.
"I’m glad it’s not like what happened in Mexico a few years ago," Davidson said, referring to the 2016 Mexican Grand Prix where Verstappen’s third-place finish was controversially taken away and later given to Daniel Ricciardo. "That was ridiculous. We can’t be doing that. Fans should know the result they saw on Sunday, not find out later that it’s different." Davidson believes that in-race calls provide clarity and ensure that the outcome of the race remains consistent with what was witnessed on the track.
Davidson’s Journey in Formula 1
Davidson’s understanding of Formula 1 is rooted in his own experiences as a driver. From a young age, he was introduced to motorsport by his father, a passionate F1 fan. Watching races with his father, Davidson was inspired by legendary figures like Murray Walker and James Hunt. His journey into the sport began with go-karting at the age of eight, and he eventually made his way to Formula 1, racing for Minardi, BAR, and Super Aguri.
Despite coming from a “normal” financial background, Davidson made it to F1 through hard work and dedication, a journey he takes great pride in. He raced 24 times in F1 before moving to endurance racing, where he found success, including winning the World Endurance Championship. In addition to his work as a commentator, Davidson also contributes to Mercedes’ F1 simulator development.
Davidson’s Thoughts on Formula 1’s Competitive Nature
Davidson has always been known as a fierce competitor on track, and he admits that his racing style may not have always aligned with the cutthroat nature of Formula 1. "Inside the car I was a hard racer, but outside the car I was probably not hard enough," Davidson reflected. He noted that Formula 1 is a very demanding sport, where drivers must be not only strong on track but also assertive off track to succeed.
Despite this, Davidson believes that being "nice" is not necessarily a disadvantage in the sport. "Once the visor was down, I became something else. It felt like my superpower," he said. "But there were moments in my career where being more confident and demanding outside the car could have helped me." Nonetheless, Davidson’s reflections on his career offer valuable insights into the complexities of both racing and the role of F1 analysts and stewards.
Conclusion: The Role of Stewards and Analysts in F1
As Formula 1 continues to evolve, the role of stewards and analysts like Anthony Davidson remains crucial in ensuring that the sport operates with fairness and transparency. While fans may sometimes disagree with stewarding decisions, it’s important to recognize the challenges that stewards face in making quick, informed choices based on the rulebook. Davidson’s candid insights into the stewarding process, along with his own experiences in F1, offer a unique perspective on how the sport is governed and analyzed both on and off the track.
Up Next
