U.S. GP Norris-Verstappen drama: questions about F1 penalties

Red Bull Racing/Red Bull Content Pool

Norris-Verstappen U.S. GP duel sparks debate over F1 stewards' decisions.

AUSTIN, Texas — Ferrari celebrating a commendable one-two finish overshadowed by disputes over the rules. In a hotly debated ruling at the U.S. Grand Prix, McLaren's Lando Norris received a five-second penalty after overtaking Red Bull's Max Verstappen beyond the white line at the edge of the circuit.

The stewards cited Norris for "leaving the circuit and gaining a lasting advantage."

The spectacle was marred by a five-second time penalty issued to Lando Norris after a dramatic tussle with championship contender Max Verstappen for the final podium position. The penalty, assigned for Norris making an off-track overtake on Verstappen, reversed their finishing order at the line and enabled Verstappen to extend his lead in the drivers’ championship by six points.

Such developments in the title race have reignited debates concerning the consistency of F1’s stewarding and the rationality of racing regulations.

Inside the controversial clash

Norris, determined to reclaim his position from Verstappen after relinquishing it at the chaotic Turn 1 on the opening lap, charged through the field. The initial overtake by Verstappen, not deemed worthy of investigation due to the hectic nature of the first corner, saw both drivers briefly traversing the run-off area, which allowed Ferrari's Charles Leclerc to seize the lead.

Following the opening exchanges, the race settled with Verstappen in second and Norris in fourth. A later pit stop strategy saw Norris equipped with fresher tires, offering him an advantage in the closing stages.

On lap 52, Norris used his superior grip and the Drag Reduction System (DRS) to draw alongside Verstappen down the long straight to Turn 12. However, Verstappen out-braked himself, both cars overshooting the corner and venturing off the track. Norris returned in front of Verstappen, moving into third place and began to establish a gap.

Verstappen quickly communicated with his team via radio, urging that Norris should concede the position. Not long after, race stewards confirmed their investigation into the incident, culminating in the penalty for Norris.

The ramifications of this incident have become a talking point in paddocks and media alike, with the current rules and stewarding decisions under scrutiny as the championship battle heats up.

Norris penalised for overtake on Verstappen: stewards' complex decision explained

The Incident and immediate response

Norris, overtaking Verstappen on the outside, believed he was ahead at the apex, a critical point in determining track position according to the "Driving Standards Guidelines." Over team radio, Norris asked if he'd been ahead at the apex, and the team incorrectly confirmed this, leading to the initial non-compliance with the stewards' warning.

Verstappen, defending his position, also left the track's confines. This action could be viewed as "forcing another driver off the track." Historically, both transgressions are punishable by 10-second penalties, though mitigating circumstances often lead to five-second penalties.

Stewards' reasoning

In their decision, the stewards referenced the Driving Standards Guidelines, introduced in 2022, which state a driver overtaking on the outside loses the "right" to the corner if they are behind at the apex. According to the stewards, because Norris was not level with Verstappen at the apex and then left the track, he gained an unfair advantage.

Stewards detailed, "[Norris] was overtaking [Verstappen] on the outside, but was not level with [Verstappen] at the apex. Therefore, under the Driving Standards Guidelines, [Norris] had lost the 'right' to the corner. Accordingly, as [Norris] left the track and returned in front of [Verstappen], it is deemed to be a case of leaving the track and gaining a lasting advantage."

The stewards imposed a five-second penalty on Norris, deducing he had little alternative but to leave the track due to Verstappen's proximity, who had also left the track.

Norris and Verstappen respond

Norris expressed his dissatisfaction, suggesting Verstappen’s move forced him off the track in a manner inconsistent with fair racing standards.

"For me, the point that is incorrect is what Max did, which is defend his position by going off the track," Norris stated. "He went off the track by defending, and has overdefended and made a mistake, and therefore has gained from that."

Conversely, Verstappen underscored the clarity of the rules: "It's very clear in the rules. Outside the white line, you cannot pass. I've been done for it as well in the past."

Team principals weigh in

Red Bull team principal, Christian Horner, acknowledged the complexities faced by the stewards and suggested that clarity in such situations comes down to team strategy: "What I perhaps didn't understand was it was clear there was going to be a penalty, or it looked pretty clear there was going to be a penalty, and with the car advantage and tyre advantage that McLaren had at that point of the race, it looked like Lando went to give the place back up at Turn 1, but there was some confusion there."

McLaren's Andrea Stella argued that Verstappen forced Norris off the track and that the investigation should have focused on Verstappen's actions. Stella elaborated, "I think the 'ahead at the apex' in relation to the interpretation of the overtaking manoeuvre is not the relevant bit. I think [Verstappen] goes just straight at the apex."

Stella also suggested that such nuanced incidents should be reviewed post-race for a thorough understanding: "They should have respect for their job as well, and when the case is so difficult, like Lando and Max, just take the time, review it after the race, hear from the drivers, try to understand the subtleties."

Championship impact

For Norris, this penalty widens the gap to Verstappen in the championship race. Before the U.S. Grand Prix, Norris trailed by 52 points, and with the penalty, the deficit has increased to 57 points. With only five races remaining, Norris' hopes to overcome Verstappen are dwindling.

"It's a momentum killer," Norris admitted. "The fact that Ferrari were so quick today showed they're just as competitive. The one guy I need to beat is Max, and that's the guy I didn't beat today."

The outcome in Austin has left Norris and his team needing to reassess strategies to close the gap in the remaining races, emphasizing the competitive and unpredictable nature of Formula 1 racing.

Up Next